Human Rights Lawyer Tran Vu Hai and His Wife Convicted of Tax Evasion, Sentenced to One-year Non-custodial Reform
Defend the Defenders, November 15, 2019
On November 15, the People’s Court of Nha Trang city, Khanh Hoa province convicted human rights attorney Tran Vu Hai and his wife Ngo Tuyet Phuong and two local citizens of tax evasion under Article 161 of the 1999 Penal Code, Defend the Defenders has learned.
The couple was sentenced to one year of non-custodial reform and was ordered to pay an administrative fine of VND20 million ($850) each for the crime they have not committed, according to the lawyers providing legal assistance for the experienced couple attorneys.
According to the indictment against them, they were accused of committing a tax evasion worth VND276 million in a property deal in 2014. Mr. Hai and his wife reportedly bought a land parcel from Khanh Hoa province-based citizens Nguyen Thi Ngoc Hanh and Ngo Van Lam. The deal value was about VND16 billion but they reported to the local authorities just VND1.8 billion, by that way the sellers paid less tax for the deal. The province’s tax authorities had approved the deal.
As many as more than 60 lawyers had been registered to the court to voluntarily defense for the couple. However, many of them were denied and only around 40 were allowed to attend the trial which was treated as a political one since the local authorities deployed a large number of police officers to block all the roads leading to the court areas and the lawyers were under strict security check-up before entering the courtroom. They were requested to leave all electrical devices, including laptops and cell phones outside. A few reporters of the state-run newspapers were allowed to enter the courtroom to cover the trial.
The defense lawyers said as buyers, Mr. Hai and his wife are not subjects for tax payment for the deal, and they are innocent since the province’s tax authorities approved the deal. Ms. Hanh is a citizen of Belgium so the case should be handled by an upper court and the Nha Trang city’s People’s Court is not eligible for the case. In addition, the property Ms. Hanh sold to Mr. Hai was the only house she owned so she is not required to pay tax for the deal, according to current Vietnam’s law.
The trial lasted three days, longer than other cases with similar characters. On the first day, one of the defense attorneys, Nguyen Duy Binh was rudely expelled out of the courtroom and was taken out by two policemen after questioning Ms. Hanh about her legal representation. Binh was interrogated for hours in a local police station.
Authorities in Khanh Hoa probed the case in early July and placed the four under restricted travel, including travel abroad. In addition, Khanh Hoa police also conducted searching Mr. Hai’s law office and a private residence in Hanoi, in which they allegedly took away a large sum of money and documents from other cases.
It is clear that the allegation and convictions against Mr. Hai and his wife are political as recently the Ministry of Public Security denied Mr. Hai’s request for representing former prisoner of conscience Truong Duy Nhat who is accused of “power abuse” after being kidnapped in Bangkok and taken to Vietnam in late January.
Lawyer Hai is well-known for his participation in sensitive cases to represent victims of injustice, victims of forced land appropriation and political dissidents.
Vietnamese Well-known Facebooker Threatened with Heavy Punishment For Disseminating News on Covid-19
March 28, 2020
Bộ Công an đã xử lý hơn 300 trường hợp đưa tin sai sự thật về dịch COVID-19
March 27, 2020
Mandates of the the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression; Working Group on Arbitrary Detention; the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association; and the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders
March 27, 2020
CIVICUS: States should put human rights at the centre of all responses to COVID-19
March 26, 2020
LHQ chất vấn chính phủ Việt Nam: “Phạm Chí Dũng bị bắt vì kêu gọi hoãn EVFTA”
March 25, 2020
Làm thế nào để người hoạt động đối phó với sự ép buộc phải thú tội trên truyền hình
March 25, 2020
Tuần tin Người Bảo vệ Nhân quyền, tuần thứ 12 từ ngày 16/3 đến 22/3/2020: Nhiều nhà hoạt động bị sách nhiễu trong khi đại dịch Covid-19 hoành hành
March 23, 2020
Vietnam Human Rights Defenders’ Weekly Report for March 16-22, 2020: Activists Continuously Being Harassed, Intimidated amid Covid-19 Outbreak
March 23, 2020
Vietnam Jails Two Hmong Men For Life in Alleged Campaign to Set up Separate Ethnic State
March 20, 2020
Hmong Accused of Subversion: Two with Life Imprisonment, Nine Others with Total 84 Years in Jail
March 19, 2020